| 1999 | Name | Total | Total Games | Percentage | Years | ||||
| Name | Total | Total Games | Percentage | * Kevin Morrissey | 401 | 632 | 63.45% | 3 | |
| * Scott Manning | 141 | 216 | 65.28% | * Mike Novak | 397 | 632 | 62.82% | 3 | |
| * William Morrissey | 91 | 142 | 64.08% | * Joe Bilinski Sr. | 247 | 387 | 63.82% | 2 | |
| * Mike Novak | 157 | 245 | 64.08% | * Lisa Hieber | 389 | 632 | 61.55% | 3 | |
| * Joe Bilinski | 156 | 245 | 63.67% | * Scott Manning | 381 | 603 | 63.18% | 3 | |
| * Lisa Hieber | 152 | 245 | 62.04% | * William Morrissey | 325 | 529 | 61.44% | 3 | |
| * Kevin Morrissey | 149 | 245 | 60.82% | * Brad Hieber | 381 | 632 | 60.28% | 3 | |
| * Brad Hieber | 143 | 245 | 58.37% | * Jeff Natalucci | 85 | 141 | 60.28% | 1 | |
| * Joe Bilinski | 395 | 632 | 62.50% | 3 | |||||
| 2000 | * John Hieber III | 234 | 387 | 60.47% | 2 | ||||
| Name | Total | Total Games | Percentage | * Tom Braden | 240 | 387 | 62.02% | 2 | |
| * Tom Braden | 162 | 246 | 65.85% | John Hieber | 210 | 387 | 54.26% | 2 | |
| * Kevin Morrissey | 158 | 246 | 64.23% | Ivi Santos | 70 | 112 | 62.50% | 1 | |
| * Joe Bilinski Sr. | 155 | 246 | 63.01% | ||||||
| * Joe Bilinski | 154 | 246 | 62.60% | ||||||
| * Brad Hieber | 153 | 246 | 62.20% | ||||||
| * Scott Manning | 153 | 246 | 62.20% | ||||||
| Dan Williams | 151 | 246 | 61.38% | ||||||
| John Hieber III | 151 | 246 | 61.38% | ||||||
| * Lisa Hieber | 150 | 246 | 60.98% | ||||||
| JP Sullivan | 111 | 184 | 60.33% | ||||||
| * William Morrissey | 147 | 246 | 59.76% | ||||||
| * Mike Novak | 146 | 246 | 59.35% | ||||||
| John Hieber | 138 | 246 | 56.10% | ||||||
| (thru week 10) 2001 | |||||||||
| Name | Total | Total Games | Percentage | ||||||
| * Kevin Morrissey | 94 | 141 | 66.67% | ||||||
| * Mike Novak | 94 | 141 | 66.67% | ||||||
| * Joe Bilinski Sr. | 92 | 141 | 65.25% | ||||||
| * Lisa Hieber | 87 | 141 | 61.70% | ||||||
| * Scott Manning | 87 | 141 | 61.70% | ||||||
| * William Morrissey | 87 | 141 | 61.70% | ||||||
| * Brad Hieber | 85 | 141 | 60.28% | ||||||
| * Jeff Natalucci | 85 | 141 | 60.28% | ||||||
| * Joe Bilinski | 85 | 141 | 60.28% | ||||||
| * John Hieber III | 83 | 141 | 58.87% | ||||||
| * Tom Braden | 78 | 141 | 55.32% | ||||||
| John Hieber | 72 | 141 | 51.06% | ||||||
| Ivi Santos | 70 | 112 | 62.50% |